Year
|
Work
|
Award
|
Category
|
Result
|
2007
|
Gotham Award
|
Best Ensemble Cast
|
Before the Devil Knows You're Dead
|
Won
|
2008
|
Satellite Award
|
Best Supporting Actor
|
Revolutionary Road
|
Won
|
Chicago Film Critics Association
|
Best Supporting Actor
|
Nominated
|
Detroit Film Critics Society
|
Best Supporting Actor
|
Nominated
|
St. Louis Film Critics Association
|
Best Supporting Actor
|
Nominated
|
2009
|
Palm Springs International Film Festival
|
Best Ensemble Cast
|
Won
|
Online Film Critics Society
|
Best Supporting Actor
|
Nominated
|
Santa Barbara International Film Festival
|
Virtuoso Award
|
Won
|
2011
|
Gotham Award
|
Best Ensemble Cast
|
Take Shelter
|
Nominated
|
Austin Film Critics Association
|
Best Actor
|
Won
|
Chicago Film Critics Association
|
Best Actor
|
Won
|
New York Film Critics Online
|
Best Actor
|
Won
|
San Diego Film Critics Society
|
Best Actor
|
Won
|
Toronto Film Critics Association
|
Best Actor
|
Won
|
Los Angeles Film Critics Association
|
Best Actor
|
Runner-up
|
Dallas–Fort Worth Film Critics Association
|
Best Actor
|
5th Place
|
Detroit Film Critics Society
|
Best Actor
|
Nominated
|
Houston Film Critics Society
|
Best Actor
|
Nominated
|
Online Film Critics Society
|
Best Actor
|
Nominated
|
Satellite Award
|
Best Actor
|
Nominated
|
Washington D.C. Area Film Critics Association
|
Best Actor
|
Nominated
|
2012
|
Vancouver Film Critics Circle
|
Best Actor
|
Nominated
|
Independent Spirit Award
|
Best Male Lead
|
Nominated
|
Saturn Award
|
Best Actor
|
Won
|
2015
|
Gotham Award
|
Best Actor
|
99 Homes
|
Nominated
|
Los Angeles Film Critics Association
|
Best Supporting Actor
|
Won
|
San Francisco Film Critics Circle
|
Best Supporting Actor
|
Won
|
Toronto Film Critics Association
|
Best Supporting Actor
|
Runner-up
|
Chicago Film Critics Association
|
Best Supporting Actor
|
Nominated
|
Vancouver Film Critics Circle
|
Best Supporting Actor
|
Nominated
|
Florida Film Critics Circle
|
Best Supporting Actor
|
Nominated
|
Austin Film Critics Association
|
Best Supporting Actor
|
Nominated
|
National Society of Film Critics
|
Best Supporting Actor
|
2nd Place
|
Alliance of Women Film Journalists
|
Best Supporting Actor
|
Nominated
|
Critics' Choice Award
|
Best Supporting Actor
|
Nominated
|
Houston Film Critics Society
|
Best Supporting Actor
|
Nominated
|
Independent Spirit Award
|
Best Supporting Male
|
Nominated
|
Saturn Award
|
Best Supporting Actor
|
Nominated
|
2016
|
Washington D.C. Area Film Critics Association
|
Best Supporting Actor
|
Nocturnal Animals
|
Nominated
|
St. Louis Film Critics Association
|
Best Supporting Actor
|
Nominated
|
Critics' Choice Award
|
Best Supporting Actor
|
Nominated
|
Toronto Film Critics Association
|
Best Supporting Actor
|
Runner-up
|
Florida Film Critics Circle
|
Best Supporting Actor
|
Nominated
|
San Francisco Film Critics Circle
|
Best Supporting Actor
|
Nominated
|
Online Film Critics Society
|
Best Supporting Actor
|
Nominated
|
Austin Film Critics Association
|
Best Supporting Actor
|
Nominated
|
Chicago Film Critics Association
|
Best Supporting Actor
|
Nominated
|
IndieWire Critics Poll
|
Best Supporting Actor
|
9th Place
|
Alliance of Women Film Journalists
|
Nominated
|
San Diego Film Critics Society
|
Best Supporting Actor
|
Nominated
|
Dallas–Fort Worth Film Critics Association
|
Best Supporting Actor
|
3rd Place
|
National Society of Film Critics
|
Best Supporting Actor
|
3rd Place
|
Houston Film Critics Society
|
Best Supporting Actor
|
Nominated
|
AACTA International Award
|
Best Supporting Actor
|
Nominated
|
London Film Critics' Circle
|
Supporting Actor of the Year
|
Nominated
|
2017
|
St. Louis Film Critics Association
|
Best Supporting Actor
|
The Shape of Water
|
Nominated
|
Seattle Film Critics Society
|
Best Supporting Actor
|
Nominated
|
Satellite Awards
|
Best Supporting Actor
|
Nominated
|
2021
|
Satellite Awards
|
Best Supporting Actor – Series, Miniseries or Television Film
|
Nine Perfect Strangers
|
Nominated
|